Most of us think of ourselves as reasonably good listeners.
And in low-stakes situations, we probably are. But put us in the middle of a tense conversation — one where we feel criticised, misunderstood, or cornered — and something shifts. The capacity to actually hear what the other person is saying narrows dramatically.
This isn’t a character flaw. It’s physiology.
When a conversation starts to feel threatening, the nervous system responds before the thinking brain has a chance to catch up. You move into fight/flight/freeze. And from that state, your brain is no longer taking in information accurately — it’s filtering everything through the question: am I safe here? What’s coming next?
The result is that you stop hearing what your partner is actually saying and start hearing your worst interpretation of it. You’re not really listening anymore. You’re bracing.
No wonder so many difficult conversations go in circles.
—
WHY WE SKIP TO PROBLEM-SOLVING
There’s another common move that gets in the way of listening, and it’s more well-intentioned: the rush to fix things.
When conflict is uncomfortable — and it usually is — there’s a strong pull toward finding a solution quickly. If we can just resolve the issue, the discomfort will go away.
The problem is that trying to solve something before the other person feels genuinely heard rarely works. They don’t feel understood, so the solution doesn’t land. The same issue comes back. You wonder why.
Feeling listened to isn’t a nice extra step before the real work begins. It is the real work. People can’t engage productively with solutions until they feel their experience has been received.
—
LISTENING IS A SKILL — AND IT CAN BE PRACTISED
The good news is that listening during conflict is something you can get better at. Not by trying harder in the moment, but by practising it regularly when the stakes are lower.
Like most skills, it’s easier to develop in conditions where you’re not already activated. Once your nervous system is escalated and you’re in the middle of a charged conversation, accessing new behaviours is genuinely hard. But if you’ve practised them when things are calm, they become more available when things aren’t.
—
THE 5-MINUTE LISTENING EXPERIMENT
This is a simple exercise worth trying with a partner or a friend — ideally when things are going well between you, not in the middle of a conflict.
Set aside about 10 minutes. Decide who will speak first and who will listen. Set a timer for 5 minutes. Then switch.
Start with something relatively low-stakes — a work situation, something you’ve been thinking about, a decision you’re navigating. Save the harder topics for when this feels more natural.
IF YOU’RE LISTENING:
Notice when you feel genuinely curious — and when you feel defensive or like you want to respond, correct, or problem-solve. You don’t have to act on either. Just notice the difference.
Let yourself feel how strange it is to simply receive what someone is saying without needing to do anything with it.
Remember that your partner is sharing their perspective — not delivering a verdict. Listening doesn’t mean you agree. It means you’re interested in understanding how they see it.
IF YOU’RE SPEAKING:
This is a genuinely rare opportunity — to say what you actually think or feel without being interrupted or redirected. Use it.
Try to stay with your own experience rather than moving into accusations or blame. “I felt hurt when…” lands differently than “you always…”
When the 5 minutes ends, thank the other person for listening. It’s worth naming.
—
WHAT YOU TEND TO NOTICE
Most people are surprised by a few things the first time they try this.
How hard it is to just listen without responding. How much of our usual “listening” is actually waiting for a gap. How different it feels to be on the receiving end of real attention.
That difference — between being truly heard and being processed — is something most of us have experienced, but rarely in close relationships where the stakes are highest.
This experiment won’t transform your communication overnight. But it can give you a felt sense of what genuine listening actually is — which makes it easier to move toward in the moments when it matters most.
—
If you find that conflict in your relationship consistently goes somewhere neither of you wants it to go — that conversations escalate quickly, or that you both end up feeling unheard — that’s often worth exploring in relationship counselling. The patterns that make listening hard in conflict usually have roots worth understanding.
